NFL TV analyst rankings: Fox, CBS No. 2s are No. 1 quality

Posted

Are you aware of the forthcoming football feast?

Next week, NFL games will appear on a TV near you on Wednesday, Thursday, Friday, Sunday and Monday. That’s five out of six days with NFL action. That has to be a first in world history.

Those five days will feature seven stand-alone games on — try to follow me — Netflix, CBS, Fox, NBC, Prime Video and ESPN.

You might say that’s a lot of games. I say that’s a lot of broadcasters.

This season, analysts have been in the spotlight. It began with CBS dumping Tony Romo and promoting J.J. Watt. It continued with Troy Aikman feeling betrayed by Joe Buck — ESPN gave Buck a new contract, not Aikman — and the rapid rise of newcomers.

In that spirit, let’s do what this column does best — or at least does — rank things. The star of a football TV broadcast is supposed to be the analyst, like the great John Madden was. So let’s examine analysts. Here are our top 10, most of whom you’ll see next week.

1. Greg Olsen, Fox

Fox’s No. 2 analyst is No. 1 in my heart. If not for Tom Brady, Olsen still would be on the top crew with Kevin Burkhardt. Olsen is as enthusiastic and as knowledgeable as they come. He’s detail-oriented and is able to explain those intricacies succinctly. But don’t expect him to be with Fox much longer. With Aikman on the outs at ESPN and Watt on a first-team tryout at CBS, Olsen could be a No. 1 analyst again next season.

2. Troy, Aikman, ESPN

Speaking of Aikman, he has been the gold standard for years. A Hall of Fame quarterback and three-time Super Bowl champion, he has great insight and strong opinions. He isn’t afraid to call out anyone — even his partner. Though his 25-year run with Buck is nearing the end, they continue to put on a professional broadcast. If Aikman doesn’t join a team’s front office, he’ll be a No. 1 analyst elsewhere next season, perhaps competing with Olsen.

3. Cris Collinsworth, NBC

Collinsworth is a polarizing figure. Critics are nauseated by his adoration for particular players (cough, Patrick Mahomes, cough) and his tendency to spout what teams tell him when he should know better. But he has a keen eye, a sharp wit and opinions. Breaking down plays is great. Telling viewers what you think is even better.

4. Tom Brady, Fox

The GOAT quarterback is far from being the GOAT analyst — could anyone ever unseat Madden? — but he has the potential to be one of the best. He just needs to be more consistent. Brady has moments of sharp insight and others of useless interjections (“Ooohhh!”). Fox is paying him $375 million to use words. He’ll call Saints-Bears on Sunday.

5. Drew Brees, Fox

Brees has improved so much since he clammed up alongside Mike Tirico during a 2022 playoff game on NBC. He has given Fox great analyst depth after Brady and Olsen. Brees had a strong showing on the Vikings-Packers broadcast last week, particularly for explaining route combinations. He and Adam Amin have made a fine duo.

6. Ross Tucker, CBS

When Watt joined Jim Nantz on the top team, Tucker joined Ian Eagle on the second team. They had called “Thursday Night Football” together on Westwood One, and they picked up where they left off. Tucker, who also had been on CBS’ sixth crew, is excellent at breaking down blocking schemes as a rare former offensive lineman in the booth.

7. J.J. Watt, CBS

Watt blossomed last season as a rookie game analyst alongside Eagle. He hasn’t been quite as good this season as he tries to mesh with Nantz. That has led to the belief that Eagle brings out more in his partners than Nantz, particularly after Romo’s fall from grace. But Watt has his moments, such as Sunday when he caught Falcons right tackle Jawaan Taylor tipping plays.

8. Kirk Herbstreit, Prime Video

This was an odd hire from the start. It’s not that Herbstreit is bad at the job. It’s that he’s so embedded in ESPN’s coverage of college football, he can’t possibly be as attuned to the pro game as he needs to be. That comes through on the broadcast.

9. Luke Kuechly, Netflix

The former Panthers linebacker is the next rising star among NFL analysts. He’ll call the Packers-Rams game Wednesday with Noah Eagle. They called 49ers-Rams in Australia in Week 1, and Kuechly received positive reviews for astute, detailed analysis.

10. Daryl Johnston, Fox

Aikman gets a lot of plaudits for his longevity, but “Moose” has been in the booth just as long. He has been all over Fox’s depth chart, moving up to the No. 2 team when Buck and Aikman left the network. Johnston always has been solid. He doesn’t draw a lot of attention, which isn’t bad.

REMOTE PATROL

NBC 5 gets Bears on Netflix

On Christmas Day, Netflix will broadcast the Packers-Bears game, and fans who don’t subscribe to the streaming service will wonder where they can watch the game. The answer: NBC 5.

The NFL mandates that games carried by streamers or cable channels must air on over-the-air stations in the teams’ local markets. With NBC Sports handling the game production for Netflix, NBC 5 will carry the game in the Chicago market.

NBC 5 had the Bears’ game against the Buccaneers two weeks ago, and it has a chance for one more if the NFL flexes the Week 13 game against the Jaguars.

ESPN drops in-game ticker

When ESPN introduced the BottomLine in 1995, it was a revelation. But today, with everyone holding their phone while they watch games, is it necessary?

ESPN doesn’t think so. After initially removing the ticker from its college football broadcasts, the network has removed it from all live games across its networks. The BottomLine will appear during studio programming and to announce programming changes.

The network said removing the ticker provides a “cleaner presentation,” and that’s true, especially considering the size of its scorebugs. Smart move by the Worldwide Leader.