EXCLUSIVE: Inside the Lindsay Clancy Jury Notes That Led to a Mistrial

Posted

Lindsay Clancy’s defense team has taken their fight to Massachusetts’ highest court.

Clancy’s legal team continues to argue that she should never face a second murder trial after a deadlocked jury failed to reach a verdict in September.

The latest comes as Los Angeles Magazine obtained transcripts of previously private sidebar discussions through a Supreme Judicial Court request. The transcripts disclose tense conversations between Kevin Reddington and Judge William Sullivan over how the court handled the now-infamous holdout juror accused of not following the law.

Sullivan later denied the defense’s request to further investigate the holdout juror, following a frenzy of media attention and a subsequent NBC10 report about the juror’s past.

Clancy’s retrial has been scheduled for March 29, 2027, with her next hearing set for Dec. 30, 2026, and a pretrial conference scheduled for Feb. 18. Her attorneys have other plans: they are now asking the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court to step in before she is forced to stand trial again.

In a petition filed Nov. 16, attorneys Marty Weinberg, Michael Pabian and Reddington argue that Sullivan declared a mistrial without further investigating reports that one juror was not applying the court’s instructions to his deliberations. The filing also pushes back on Sullivan’s Nov. 9 decision denying Clancy’s motion to dismiss the charges on double-jeopardy grounds.

The defense maintains that Sullivan had other options, including questioning the jury foreperson more thoroughly or potentially removing a juror who was unable or unwilling to follow the law. Sullivan previously acknowledged the delicate nature of jury deliberations, explaining that he had to tread carefully to avoid probing which way jurors were leaning.

A mistrial was declared, leaving Clancy open to another prosecution for the January 2023 deaths of her three children in Duxbury, Massachusetts.

The argument began Sept. 3, when the jury foreperson sent Sullivan a note stating:

“A member of the jury is unable to follow the instructions regarding reasonable doubt. How should we proceed?”

The judge proposed questioning jurors individually about whether they could follow his instructions, without specifically addressing reasonable doubt. ADA Jennifer Sprague argued that the court should just repeat the reasonable doubt instructions over questioning each juror separately.

Reddington objected, arguing that the foreperson’s note brought up a more serious issue about a juror who was potentially refusing to follow the law.

The defense wanted additional questioning to determine whether that juror should be removed, and he wanted it in open court. Sullivan ultimately questioned each juror individually, and all indicated they could follow his instructions. But the defense argued the questions were too general to determine whether the juror in question was actually applying the law.

The argument continued at sidebar, where the newly obtained transcripts reveal that Reddington repeatedly pushed back on the judge’s handling of the issue. “My client doesn’t even know what’s going on here, Judge,” Reddington told Sullivan, according to the transcript. “This is too important to have at the sidebar and to decide to re-instruct based on that.”

He added, “She’s entitled to know what’s going on.”

Reddington insisted that the arguments should be heard in open court, rather than at sidebar.

“We’re trying the case at the sidebar. It’s not right,” he told Sullivan. At another point, Reddington became frustrated, telling the judge: “It’s just not right. It stinks. It’s not right, Judge.”

Sullivan pushed back.

“Well, I don’t think it stinks,” the judge responded.

Reddington apologized, but continued to argue that the proceedings should be public.

“I’m trying to do the best I can here,” Sullivan told him. “I don’t appreciate the personal attacks.”

Reddington responded that he was not attacking the judge personally, but objecting to how the court was handling an important issue involving the jury.

The judge eventually permitted Reddington to make his arguments in open court. Later on Sept. 3, the foreperson sent another note stating that a juror “has made statements acknowledging doubt, but refuses to apply it to the verdict as the law states.”

Credit: Commonwealth of Massachusetts SCJ

The defense argues that the notes suggest an 11-1 division, with one juror potentially refusing to return a not guilty verdict despite acknowledging reasonable doubt. Prosecutors disagreed with the defense’s interpretation, arguing that the notes may reflect an ordinary disagreement among jurors about how the law should be applied.

Sullivan declined to conduct an additional investigation requested by the defense, again expressing concern about intruding into jury deliberations.

On Sept. 4, the jury determined they would not be able to reach a unanimous verdict, and Sullivan declared a mistrial. The defense believes that the mistrial was avoidable and that Sullivan failed to investigate the foreperson’s concerns. They say this violated Clancy’s constitutional protections.

In the Nov. 16 petition, the defense states that after seven weeks of trial, 11 jurors believed prosecutors had failed to prove Clancy’s guilt beyond a reasonable doubt, while a lone holdout allegedly refused to follow the court’s instructions. The petition wants the Supreme Judicial Court to review Sullivan’s ruling and determine whether a second trial would violate the constitutional protection against double jeopardy.

Under the law, a mistrial declared over a defendant’s objection generally should be supported by what courts call “manifest necessity,” meaning there was a compelling reason to end the trial without a verdict. Clancy’s attorneys argue that standard was not met because Sullivan failed to fully explore any alternatives before dismissing the jury.

The defense would like the Supreme Judicial Court to hear oral arguments on this (before one judge), and then refer the matter to the full court.

Sullivan’s ruling remains in place, and Clancy’s second trial is scheduled to begin March 29, 2027.

The post EXCLUSIVE: Inside the Lindsay Clancy Jury Notes That Led to a Mistrial appeared first on LAmag.

Crime, Judge William Sullivan, Kevin Reddington, Lindsay Clancy, Massachusetts, Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court, Reasonable Doubt