Consumer Reports: At-home health tests may cause confusion without doctor’s guidance

Posted

The risks of DIY home health tests

Your morning continues with local news, weather and the stories that matter to central Indiana.

At-home health tests can produce confusing results and unnecessary worry, according to a Consumer Reports investigation reported by News 8’s Joseph Viney.

Full-body scans have gained attention, with celebrities promoting full-body MRIs on social media as preventive health care. The scans are marketed as able to detect stage 1 cancerous tumors and more than 500 other conditions.

These scans are not medical tests ordered by a physician, and insurance does not cover them. At about $2,500, they are beyond the reach of many consumers, even with discount codes shared by influencers who received their scans for free.

The American College of Radiology says there is no clear evidence that these total-body screenings prolong the lives of healthy people.

Consumer Reports also questions direct-to-consumer genetic test kits, which offer information about a person’s predisposition to certain illnesses, cancers or differences in metabolism. The kits do not automatically include advice from a medical professional.

As one speaker put it, “Of course, people are going to ask questions to their friends or the online forums or chat GPT, which is not a great way to really understand the implications of what these tests are telling you about your health.”

A direct-to-consumer genetic test may provide a less complete analysis of disease risk than a test ordered by a doctor as part of regular medical care.

“When your doctor orders a genetic test for you, they’re looking for something really specific. And it’s sort of like you’re fishing for a particular fish in a part of the ocean where you know that fish lives,” one speaker said. “Whereas a direct-to-consumer genetic test is more like throwing a net into the ocean and seeing what comes back.”

Consumer Reports recommends sharing all health concerns with a doctor, who can order tests that are needed and more likely to be covered by insurance. More information is available at wishtv.com.

Health Wellness, News, Newsletter