Chicago Public Schools spent nearly $100M on extra pay in 2025, Office of Inspector General reports finds

Posted

A new watchdog report found that the financially strapped Chicago Public Schools spent nearly $100 million on overtime and other extra pay during the 2024-25 school year, an 83% increase since the last year before the COVID-19 pandemic.

The Chicago Board of Education's Office of Inspector General released the report Monday morning, which shows the district spent $97 million on extra pay in Fiscal Year 2025 – the most recent year tracked by the OIG – including extended days, overtime, and stipends.

The district's inspector general warned of the problem years ago, and while some improvements have been made, CPS Inspector General Philip Wagenknecht is disappointed the district didn't do more sooner.

While spending on extra pay in 2025 was down from the three previous years, the report found it's still far higher than before the pandemic – nearly double the amount paid in Fiscal Year 2019.

The report found the increase is because the board did not listen to recommendations to implement guardrails on extra pay, like monitoring pay by schools, departments and individuals and establishing cutoffs that would trigger extra scrutiny. A 2022 review on extra pay warned that such spending might continue to rise unchecked without such guardrails, especially with the available federal COVID relief funding.

The report found that in 2025, CPS spent $42.6 million on extended day pay, $36.6 million on overtime pay and $17.8 million on stipend pay.  The OIG said the "unusually large amounts" of extra pay raised several serious concerns, including worries that too many hours worked will lead to lower productivity, low morale, burnout, high absenteeism and high turnover. The report also warns the spending can indicate favoritism in assigning extra pay, or show hiring needs have not been assessed realistically.

The report found some employees were paid for overtime hours that indicate unhealthy work environments. One custodian punched in and out of work for 77 days in a row, including weekends, in the fall, the report said. Another was paid for nearly 98 hours of overtime worked in a two-week period in the winter. A third was paid nearly 100 hours of overtime for working all 14 days in a pay period with no days off.

For a district that faced a deficit of more than $700 million going into this school year, tens of millions in unapproved overtime is a head scratcher.

According to the report, the biggest blind spot when it came to extra pay was janitorial workers. Some are doubling their annual salary, working hours that haven't been approved, getting paid tens of thousands in extra pay.

"The records for the overtime work were not great, and they showed that the overtime that was worked was only approved 25% of the time," Wagenknecht said. "And, you know, from our standpoint, CPS needs to be making sure that they're preventing waste and fraud, which we've seen happens over the years."

After a report this spring, CPS placed new limits on extended day pay for teachers. Wagenknecth was pleased with that.

In Fiscal Year 2024, CPS spent $150 million on extra pay, so $97 million last year is a significant reduction, but still far higher than before the pandemic.

Wagenknecht said other school districts of similar size have better guardrails to prevent this from happening, and CPS needs to catch up.

The Los Angeles Unified School District's overtime policy caps employees' overtime at 528 hours per school year, and they are not allowed to work more than 44 overtime hours without extra approval in "extreme emergencies." Wagenknecht's office noted the Houston Independent School District and New York City Schools cap overtime pay to 5% of the employees' total annual pay each fiscal year, and both have supervisors or written procedures to ensure the cap isn't exceeded or is exceeded only in extraordinary circumstances.

"Several of the other large school districts across the country impose similar limits that we've recommended in this case," Wagenknecht said. "CPS is just starting to do that now at our recommendation, but I think I think we've seen that CPS is maybe a little bit out of step with what other districts are doing, and I think that it's a good sign that now they're moving in that direction."

The report notes that with COVID relief funding no longer available and the district facing a budget gap of more than $730 million, "controlling and reducing Extra Pay spending is crucial."

The district said it is implementing some of the office's key recommendations in the wake of the report, including a cap on one form of extra pay, though CPS is still evaluating whether to implement the report's recommendations on overtime pay.

Local News, Syndicated Local, Education